Insurance Claim Games | Blumenshine Law Group

Insurance Company Claims Games

insurance claim games

Insurance “games”? Insurance is serious business right? You buy insurance for the peace of mind you are provided against unforeseen loss. Insurance company advertisements promise the warm fuzzies of protection to you and your family.

And certainly, many claims are paid promptly and fully. Certainly, some claims are without merit and are properly denied. What is unacceptable, however, are insurance company claims handling procedures that are used for the sole purpose of delaying and denying meritorious claims.

What are insurance company claims games?

Any insurance company claims handling activity that is motivated by the goal of improperly delaying or denying a claim payment may be part of a “game” that you may not be prepared to “play”. Those of you who have encountered an insurance company delay or denial may have unwittingly entered the process.

We understand that insurance companies are profit motivated corporations formed and managed with the goal of returning investment to company shareholders. The courts and regulators have, however, noted that certain insurance business involve a public trust. Auto insurance policies, for example, are mandatory in order to establish some compensation for those injured on public roadways. Thus insurers must be held to a higher standard of conduct. Their actions affect the public.

What are examples of claims games?

The following activities are examples of insurance company claims games:

  • Taking statements from claimants while they are suffering the physical and emotional effects of their injuries
  • Taking statements from claimants while they are under the influence of pain and other medication due to their injuries
  • Requesting claimants to sign authorization forms disclosing private personal information
  • Advising or suggesting to claimants that they do not need legal representation
  • Attempting to settle a claim before the nature and extent of injury or damage is determined
  • Misrepresenting insurance policy provisions
  • Failing to advise of insurance policy provisions
  • Portraying itself as the claimant’s friend, counsel, or advisor
  • Making inaccurate statements about the law
  • Making inaccurate statements about the facts
  • Requesting duplicative information
  • Taking advantage of a claimant’s compromised physical and financial condition to secure an unfair settlement
  • Requiring a lawsuit to be filed in order for a claimant to recover
  • Using computer programs to determine the “value” of personal injuries
  • Failing to fully investigate a claim by, for example, not interviewing witnesses, and
  • Any tactics that unfairly use an insurance company’s position of power and  knowledge, to exploit  the insured’s position of physical and financial vulnerability, weakness, or naiveté.

Insurance Company Tactics

Anything that an insurer does to wrongfully deny a claim, delay a claim, take advantage of a claimant, frustrate the claimant, wear the claimant down, or exhaust the claimant’s resources is a game. In short, any insurance company claims tactic that is not designed to honestly and fairly evaluate and resolve a claim is a game.

I represent individual claimants. I have seen the tactics. But I do believe that is possible to make an objective determination as to what is legitimate claims evaluation and what is pure game playing. What is going on in much of the area of insurance claims handling is gamesmanship.

A prime example of claims games is demonstrated in articles that appeared in Bloomberg and the Chicago Tribune. The stories discussed the tactics of a major insurance company that seeks to put people in its “Good Hands.” The articles revealed that a major overhaul of the insurer’s claims process involved putting on “Boxing Gloves” to deal with claimants. The company denied much of the story, but those of us who toil in the field, know the Boxing Glove approach. Delay and Denial are the marching orders.

Need more information on insurance claims and the entire process? Here are some great articles on our site:

Insurance Claims for the General Practitioner

What is Trial Process

How an Illinois Jury Verdict Award Works

Ebook – Uninsured, Hit-and- Run, and Underinsured Motorist Coverage in Illinois

Scott Blumenshine - June 19, 2012

Feel free to post your stories of experiences with insurer claims games here in the comments!

Comments are closed